Picture three charming, spacious, and well-kept homes scattered in

a forest setting on two shores of a secluded, freshwater pond.


Located off State Road between West Tisbury and Vineyard Haven,

Old House Pond is a glacially formed, spring-fed jewel, just under 10 acres,

which used to provide the ice for the whole island! 


Each of the houses is on its own 4-5 acre lot, so they are not visible to each other

through the woods from clearing to clearing.  Each home offers a unique character

along with countless amenities to provide you with an idyllic vacation. 

Please note that neither pets nor smoking is permitted in any of the houses.


Click on a photo below to learn more about a house.

Three unique pond-side rental homes in the woods of West Tisbury

on Martha’s Vineyard Island

Text Box: “We’ve tried Edgartown, Chilmark and Maine, but we’re ready to swim in that fantastic pond again.” 
-Darren, NY


3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths


Studio House

Text Box: “There were loons on your pond calling some nights — so pretty.  What a wonderful spot.” 
-Denise P.

For more information on

Hilltop or Studio House,

please contact Pam Waters


Phone: 717-469-0919

Email: pswaters@hotmail.com


For more information on

New House,

please contact Jenny Brody


Phone: 301-379-1788

Email: jennyannbrody@gmail.com